Special Guest Appearance on Refuse to Lose | Félix Hernández HOF Case, Dave Sims, Yankees Offseason, Mets–Mariners Trade Fit, Jorge Polanco & More | BONUS

This is not a numbered Tablesetters episode and not our standard show format. What you’re hearing here is our segment from a recent guest appearance on Refuse to Lose, the Seattle Mariners–focused podcast hosted by Brady Farkas. Brady was kind enough to allow us to share this portion of the discussion. Listeners should check out the full episode of Refuse to Lose for the complete conversation and broader Mariners coverage.

The discussion begins with Félix Hernández and the Hall of Fame. Rather than focusing on traditional milestones, we talk through how Hall of Fame evaluation has shifted alongside changes in pitcher usage, workload, and league context. The focus is on peak performance, era adjustment, and overall impact, and whether the evaluation framework should continue to evolve.

From there, we move to Dave Sims and his transition from Seattle to becoming the radio voice of the New York Yankees. We discuss Sims’ long tenure with the Mariners, the role broadcasters play in shaping fan experience, and why this move carries significance for both fan bases without overstating it.

We also examine the Yankees’ offseason, why it has been comparatively quiet, and whether a move like Cody Bellinger still fits their roster construction. That leads into a broader look at how Yankees fans view the Mariners within the American League landscape, and what that perception says about competitive positioning.

On the Mets side, the conversation turns to roster alignment and trade considerations, including whether the Mets and Mariners could function as logical trade partners. We also discuss Jorge Polanco’s time in Seattle and how that tenure informs expectations now that he is with the Mets.

We round out the segment with some lighter reflection, including favorite former Mets who spent time with the Mariners, favorite former Yankees who passed through Seattle, and how those player overlaps shape the way fans experience interleague and cross-division connections over time.

This is a focused baseball discussion centered on evaluation, context, and roster timing rather than breaking news or hot takes.

Thanks to Brady Farkas for having us on and for allowing us to share this segment.

🎧 Listen to the full episode of Refuse to Lose wherever you get your podcasts.
📱 Follow @RefuseToLosePod and @TablesettersPod on Instagram and X.